Criticism of Religious Typology in Max Weber’s Sociology of Religion (According to the worldly life of Masters of Ni’matullahi Order in Iran)
Abolfazl Fathabadi[1] Abstract:
Max Weber in the field of sociology of religion has had a comprehensive study about the religions of the world and has studied the links between various religions and specific social groups, and the impact of a variety of religious views on other social aspects, such as economic behavior. One of the positive and unique aspects of Weber’s sociology of religion is his religious typology and developing the ideal types of religious attitudes: Inner-worldly asceticism, World-rejecting asceticism and World-flying mysticism. The problem of this article is based on the fact that Weber has placed Sufis in "World-flying mysticism" ideal type while, this notion seems to be not true, according to the worldly life of Sufi Masters in Iran. Therefore, by means of archival research method and study of related historical sources, the worldly life of some Masters of Ni’matullahi Order in Iran was studied. Findings show that contrary to Weber's view, these Sufi Masters were hard-working persons in the field of worldly jobs, social works like public utilities and charitable acts, and educating knowledge during their lifetime. So, the three original ideal types in Weber’s religious typology, was completed by a fourth one, called Sufism which Sufis are its examples. Keywords: Sufi Masters of Iran, Sociology of Religion, Critical Approach, Max Weber, Religious Typology.
سیدین، علی (1389)، پشمینهپوشان، چ۲، تهران: انتشارات نی.
شاه نعمتالله ولی، سید نورالدین (1386)، کلیات اشعار، چ۲، کرمان: انتشارات خدمات فرهنگی کرمان.
صدریا، مجتبی (1382)، دعا برای اشیای گمشده، ترجمۀ داود طبایی، چ۱، تهران: دفتر پژوهشهای فرهنگی و مرکز بینالمللی گفتگوی تمدنها.
عطار نیشابوری، شیخ فریدالدین (1388)، تذکرة الاولیاء، با مقدمۀ جواد سلماسیزاده، چ۴، تهران: انتشارات دُر.
فتحآبادی، ابوالفضل (1395)، «انتقاداتی بر انواع مثالی در جامعهشناسی دین ماکس وبر»، مجلۀ جامعهشناسی ایران، دورۀ هفدهم، شمارۀ 3، 135ـ۱۵۲.
فرزام، حمید (1374)، تحقیق در احوال و نقد آثار و افکار شاه نعمتالله ولی، چ۱، تهران: انتشارات سروش.
کرمانی، عبدالرزاق (1335)، «رسالۀ تذکره در مناقب شاه نعمتالله ولی»، مجموعه احوال شاه نعمتالله ولی، تصحیح و مقدمۀ ژان ابن، چ۱، تهران: انتشارات انستیتو ایران و فرانسه.
نعمتاللهی، صنعالله (1335)، «رساله احوال و مقامات شاه نعمتالله ولی»، مجموعه احوال شاه نعمتالله ولی، تصحیح و مقدمۀ ژان ابن، چ۱، تهران: انتشارات انستیتو ایران و فرانسه.
وبر، ماکس (1395)، اخلاق پروتستانی و روح سرمایهداری، ترجمۀ رشیدیان و کاشانی، چ۶، تهران: انتشارات علمی و فرهنگی.
ـــــ (1393)، اقتصاد و جامعه، ترجمۀ عباس منوچهری و همکاران، چ۳، تهران: انتشارات سمت.
Fathabadi, A. .. (2022). .Criticism of Religious Typology in Max Weber’s Sociology of Religion
(According to the worldly life of Masters of Ni’matullahi Order in Iran). Mystical Studies, 18(1), 217-250. https://doi.org/10@22052/se.2022.113263
MLA
Fathabadi, A. .. ".Criticism of Religious Typology in Max Weber’s Sociology of Religion
(According to the worldly life of Masters of Ni’matullahi Order in Iran)", Mystical Studies, 18, 1, 2022, 217-250. doi: 10@22052/se.2022.113263
HARVARD
Fathabadi A. .. (2022). '.Criticism of Religious Typology in Max Weber’s Sociology of Religion
(According to the worldly life of Masters of Ni’matullahi Order in Iran)', Mystical Studies, 18(1), pp. 217-250. doi: 10@22052/se.2022.113263
CHICAGO
A. . Fathabadi, ".Criticism of Religious Typology in Max Weber’s Sociology of Religion
(According to the worldly life of Masters of Ni’matullahi Order in Iran)," Mystical Studies, 18 1 (2022): 217-250, doi: 10@22052/se.2022.113263
VANCOUVER
Fathabadi A. .. .Criticism of Religious Typology in Max Weber’s Sociology of Religion
(According to the worldly life of Masters of Ni’matullahi Order in Iran). Mystical Studies. 2022;18(1):217-250 (In Persian). doi: 10@22052/se.2022.113263